Guilty? | 有罪吗?

English Original

A lawyer defending a man accused of burglary tried a creative defense:

"My client merely inserted his arm into the window and removed a few trifling articles. His arm is not himself, and I fail to see how you can punish the whole individual for an offense committed by his limb."

"Well put," the judge replied. "Using your logic, I sentence the defendant's arm to one year's imprisonment. He can accompany it or not, as he chooses."

The defendant smiled. With his lawyer's assistance, he detached his artificial limb, laid it on the bench, and walked out.


中文翻译

一位为被控入室盗窃的男子辩护的律师,尝试了这样一个富有创意的辩护:

"我的当事人只是将手臂伸进窗户,拿走了几件微不足道的东西。他的手臂不等于他本人,我不明白你们怎么能因其肢体犯下的过错而惩罚整个个体。"

"说得好,"法官回应道。"按照你的逻辑,我判处被告的手臂一年监禁。他可以选择是否陪伴它。"

被告笑了。在律师的协助下,他卸下了自己的假肢,将其放在长椅上,然后走了出去。

阅读记录
请先 登录 后记录阅读完成
为这篇文章评分
点击星星进行评分(1-5分)
相关文章
The Hunter's Bet | 猎人的赌局

A boastful hunter bets he can identify animals and rifle ...

anecdote fiction
Honest Lawyer | 诚实的律师

A shrewd investment counselor interviews a lawyer who cla...

business-ethics dialogue
The Smuggler | 走私犯

A border guard is repeatedly frustrated by a smuggler who...

border-crossing fiction
A Silent Love | 无声的爱

A young couple overcomes family opposition and distance, ...

fiction inspirational
The Bait | 诱饵

Mr. Smith calls a doctor because a mouse ran into his sle...

anecdote beginner
An Arithmetic Trick | 一个数学诡计

A clever student uses flawed arithmetic logic to argue th...

educational fiction
The Stubborn Horse | 倔强的马

A novelist recovering from madness presents his psychiatr...

absurd fiction
The Same Duties | 相同的职责

A retired general rehires his former orderly, promising i...

anecdote fiction
A $250 Consultation Fee | 价值250美元的咨询

A butcher successfully charges a lawyer $8.50 for meat st...

dialogue humorous-story
The Balcony Observer | 阳台上的观察员

Parents send their son to the balcony to report neighborh...

anecdote family-life
The Amazing Pig | 神奇的猪

A homeless man discovers a heroic pig at a farmhouse, awa...

animal-tale fiction
Legal Misunderstandings | 法律误解

A wealthy lawyer invites two destitute men and their fami...

beginner fiction
The Imaginative Wife | 想象力丰富的妻子

A wife requests imaginary jewels in her portrait to play ...

anecdote fiction
How Could Anyone Stoop So Low? | 谁能如此卑劣?

A beloved but short-statured restaurant manager angrily r...

cultural-misunderstanding humor
A Moment of Courage | 生命的勇气

A man tells St. Peter about his recent act of bravery aga...

courage dialogue
A Hasty Retreat | 仓皇归途

A mountain man returns home exhausted after a week, expla...

adventure beginner
Who Is This Man? | 这个男人是谁

Charles returns home at dawn to find his wife awake. When...

beginner dialogue
My Little Buttercup | 我的小毛茛

A golfer destroys a patch of buttercups and is cursed by ...

cautionary-tale fiction
The Mysterious Letter | 神秘来信

A wife confronts her husband about a mysterious perfumed ...

beginner dialogue
Beauty of Form and Beauty of Mind | 形体之美与心灵之美

A sculptor falls for a beautiful but silent woman, valuin...

culture fiction